The House of Black or White
Am I a good man? It’s a question that I struggle with on a daily basis. I try to live according to my principles, and yet sometimes I fail. I try to treat others with the utmost respect and kindness, as I believe they should be treated.
But sometimes I fail. I try to find truth in the never-ending chaos and insanity that is life, and I fail time and time again.
And so I wonder if I am good.
Many years ago I had a very deep conversation with a good friend of mine. When I say good, he is honestly one of those people for whom being good seems to be no kind of challenge at all.
It’s like being good for him is so natural that he doesn’t even realize that there is even an option to be bad. It would be so out of character for him that it’s practically unimaginable.
So I guess you can add another character flaw to my list, because I’m incredibly jealous of him.
We were discussing the concept of agency, free will, and the choice we make regarding how we treat people. I explained to him that I thought he was a better man than I am because being bad was never an option for him. He countered that if that was true then I was the better man because I constantly had to choose.
If only he knew how hard those choices are sometimes.
For the longest time I’ve struggled with the nature/nurture question. If you’ve read my writings for any length of time, you probably see me share some of the demons of my soul.
Coming from a fairly dysfunctional childhood can do that, and yet I’ve seen people come from worse who are just naturally “good” people. I’ve also seen people come from better childhoods who turn out to be “worse”.
Reality, it seems, is long questions and very short on answers.
I struggle especially today (Sunday as I write this) because it’s Father’s Day here in the US, and so we celebrate the fathers in our lives. My relationship with my father is virtually nonexistent, and I struggle with the kind of father that I have been.
I will say that I have amazing relationships with both of my children, and they have very rarely heard me raise my voice. I have tried to parent under principles of kindness, honesty, respect and love, and they both tell me that I have been an amazing father.
But it never matters the words you hear from outside, if the words inside don’t match.
All I see are the things that I could have done better. I see the things that I could not give them that I wished I could have. I see missed opportunities, things in their lives that have been harder because I was not able to be better as a father.
I honestly believe that their goodness is not a result of my parenting, but a reflection of the wonderful men that they always were.
In short, I have to live with the knowledge that I have not been as good a father as I wanted to be, and so I struggle with the question of if I was good enough. But that is one of those questions that we will never know in this life.
Some questions don’t have answers, they have possibilities. You can spend the rest of your life beating yourself up for an answer that is never going to arrive.
And really the question isn’t for me to decide. The answer would make no difference.
Because tomorrow I’m still going to wake up and have to make those choices. Tomorrow I’m still going to wake up and have to struggle with my strengths of my weaknesses.
Tomorrow is going to be full of decisions, and all I can keep doing is making sure that I choose the one that I think is right.
Not necessarily because it will make me “good”, but because I think it’s the right thing to do.
And that’s all I can ask of myself.
— Dr. Alan Barnes
@maddrbmusings